Write an article critique paper based on one of the research articles present on Canvas only those articles listed on Canvas can be critiqued.

Write an article critique paper based on one of the research articles
present on Canvas only those articles listed on Canvas can be critiqued – if you critique a
different article, it will not be graded). If you are unclear about any of this information, please
ask.
What is an article critique paper?
An article critique is a written communication that conveys your understanding of a research
article and how it relates to the conceptual issues of interest to this course.
This article critique paper will include 5 things:
1.

o

characters) that is in ALL CAPS. This running head is left-justified
(flush left on the page). Look at the first page of these instructions,
and you will see how to set up your running head.

justified. It is in the header on the title page and all subsequent
pages.
o
and the first letter of each word is capitalized. It should be descriptive of
the paper (For this paper, you should use the title of the article you are
critiquing. The paper title can be the same title as in the Running head or it
can differ – your choice). The title should be bolded.
o
between the title and your name (see the title page here). Your name and
institutional affiliation (the name of your university) should not be bold.
o
o
New Roman font. This includes everything from the title page through the
references.
o
similar title page
2.
An article critique should briefly summarize, in your own words, the article research question
and how it was addressed in the article. Below are some things to include in your summary.

1.
2.
they manipulate the IV? How did they operationally define the DV? Be
specific with these. Define the terms independent and dependent variable
and make sure to identify how they are operationally defined in the article)
ARTICLE CRITIQUE INSTRUCTIONS
3.
Was there a random sample of participants? Was there random assignment
to groups?). How was data collected (online, in person, in a laboratory?).
4.
3.

content of the article (i.e. your own ideas in your own words). For this section, please
use the word “Critique” below the last sentence in your summary, and have the word
“Critique” flush left.

thinking in your writing. Address
address more than four, but four is the minimum.

be extraneous variables or nuisance variables)? If so, explain what the confound is
and specifically how it is impacting the results of the study. A sufficient
explanation of this will include at least one paragraph of writing.

representative of the population? Could the study be replicated if it were done
again? Why or why not?

explain what validity is, and why you believe the dependent variable was or was
not measured in a way that was valid.

alternative interpretations you can think of?


of the study you read
articles or material covered in other sections of the course

stronger than the authors claim (and why); or discuss alternative interpretations of
the results (i.e. something not mentioned by the authors) and/or what research
might provide a test between the proposed and alternate interpretations

(either theoretical or practical/applied)

presented in the article and how these problems could be corrected. If the
problems you discuss are methodological in nature, then they must be issues that
are substantial enough to affect the interpretations of the findings or arguments
presented in the article. Furthermore, for methodological problems, you must
justify not only why something is problematic but also how it could be resolved
and why your proposed solution would be preferable.

addressing a particular issue than other methods
4.

ARTICLE CRITIQUE INSTRUCTIONS

want it to be very short. In other words, take all of the information that you talked
about in the summary portion of this assignment and write it again, but this time in
only a few sentences.

study but that you can also write about it in a shorter paragraph that still emphasizes
the main points of the article. Pretend that you are writing your own literature review
for a research study, and you need to get the gist of an article that you read that helps
support your own research across to your reader. Make sure to cite the original study
(the article you are critiquing).
5.

for appropriate referencing guidelines or the Chapter 14 powerpoint).

well (though you do not need to cite other sources in this assignment – this is merely
optional IF you happen to bring in other sources). Formatting counts here, so make
sure to italicize where appropriate and watch which words you are capitalizing!
6.

Research Methods Two next semester!). As such, I want to make sure that you
develop writing skills early. This is something that needs special attention, so make
sure to proofread your papers carefully.

Writing quality will become more important in future papers, but this is where you
should start to hone your writing skills.

the FIU writing center to make sure your paper is clear, precise, and covers all needed
material. I also recommend asking a few of your group members to read over your
paper and make suggestions. You can do the same for them!

are summarizing (i.e. you do not paraphrase appropriately or cite your sources
properly), you will lose some or all of the points from writing quality, depending
on the extent of the overlap with the paper. For example, if sentences contain
only one or two words changed from a sentence in the original paper, you will
lose points from writing quality.
Please note that you do not need to refer to any other sources other than the article on which you
have chosen to write your paper. However, you are welcome to refer to additional sources if you
choose.
7.
contains a summary of all the points available to you in this paper. You must submit your
ratings for your own paper, using this rubric (essentially, you’ll grade your own paper before
you hand it in). You will upload your completed rubric to the “article critique rubric”
assignment on Canvas.
ARTICLE CRITIQUE INSTRUCTIONS

the quality of your paper and whether you meet all the criteria listed.
1.
you give a rating of 2/2 for something that is not included in your paper),
you will lose points.

this will help you to 1) make sure that you have included everything you need to include,
and 2) help you to reflect on your own writing.

exactly what to expect for your grade!
Other guidelines for the article critique papers

pages for the summary, 1.5 pages to 3 pages for the critique, one or two paragraphs for
the brief summary, and 1 page for the references page. If you are under the minimum, we
will deduct points. If you go over the maximum, we are a little more flexible (you can go
over by half page or so), but we want you to try to keep it to the maximum page.

point Times New Roman font.

even includes the references, so make sure to double space EVERYTHING

article throughout the rest of your critique. Nonetheless, you should follow proper
referencing procedures, which means that:
o
quotations and followed by a parenthetical reference to the source. “Let’s say I am
directly quoting this current sentence and the next. I would then cite it with the
author name, date of publication, and the page number for the direct quote”
(Winter, 2013, p . 4).
1.
quotes to a minimum. Paraphrase instead, but make sure you still give the
original author credit for the material by citing him or using the author’s
name (“In this article, Smith noted that …” or “In this article, the authors
noted that…”)
o
listed in a reference list.

to see if they flow well, or getting family or friends to read your work. Writing quality
will become more important in future papers, so you should start working on that now!
If you have any questions about the articles, your ideas, or your writing, please ask.
Although we won’t be able to review entire drafts of papers before they are handed in, we
are very willing to discuss problems, concerns or issues that you might have.

The article you are critiquing:

Last Completed Projects

topic title academic level Writer delivered